Find the parts of the Milburn review written for you
Pick your role to see the paragraphs that apply to you, with a plain-English note on each.
Your role
Narrow it down
Fifteen paragraphs for a local authority
Chapter 1 · Every young person learning or earning
No 16 or 17 year old NEET
Paragraph 31Ambition“The first milestone in this longer journey should be to ensure that no 16 to 17 year-old is NEET.”
In short: The law already expects every 16 and 17 year old in England to be learning or training. The first milestone is to make that true in practice.
Read paragraph 31 in full
Within 10 years, all of those young people who can participate, whether in education, training or employment, should be doing so. The first milestone in this longer journey should be to ensure that no 16 to 17 year-old is NEET. By law, in England, none of them should be. Yet nearly 57,000 16 and 17 year-olds in England currently are, while thousands more are recorded as not known. That statutory expectation must become real in practice.
Chapter 1 · Every young person learning or earningChapter 7 · A clear division of responsibility
Local authorities keep their duties for 16 and 17 year olds
Paragraph 865Recommendation“Local authorities will continue to have specific duties for 16 to 17 year-olds, to identify and track young people and to ensure that they are in education, training or a job with training until their eighteenth birthday.”
In short: Local authorities still identify and track 16 and 17 year olds, and young people with an EHCP to 25, and work with mayors on participation.
Read paragraph 865 in full
One organisation cannot deliver everything. The growth in the number of young people who are NEET is multi-causal. Many organisations have a role to play in reducing NEET rates. DWP will retain key functions but will need, for example, to share data, align referrals and integrate support for young people within the local YOS. Schools and colleges will need to identify risk and support transitions; the local NHS will be accountable for the health contribution to the Support Guarantee; and housing, social care and justice services will play key roles in supporting many disadvantaged young people. Local authorities will continue to have specific duties for 16 to 17 year-olds, to identify and track young people and to ensure that they are in education, training or a job with training until their eighteenth birthday. They will also retain their duties to identify and track young people with Education, Health and Care Plans to age 25. Each will be under a duty to work with strategic authorities to improve participation outcomes for young people. In the case of the NHS in England, as described in the Health Chapter 5, that will involve new legal duties. Legislation will also codify the duties that strategic authorities and local authorities in England need to discharge in the new system. Individual institutions will therefore remain accountable for performing their own functions, while the strategic authority will be accountable for ensuring that those functions add up to a successful participation system.
Chapter 7 · A clear division of responsibilityChapter 4 · Identifying and acting on risk
A plan and a named lead after repeated suspension
Paragraph 410Recommendation“Where a pupil is repeatedly suspended or permanently excluded, there should be a transition and participation plan with a named lead responsible for coordinating what happens next.”
In short: Act before exclusion. A pupil who is repeatedly suspended gets a plan with a named lead, held first by the school and then by the local authority, that follows them between settings.
Read paragraph 410 in full
Intervention should begin before repeated suspension or permanent exclusion occurs. The transition into secondary school provides an important opportunity to identify pupils at greatest risk, including those with SEND, care-experienced pupils and those awaiting assessment, and to review whether the support and provision around them is appropriate before problems escalate. Where a pupil is repeatedly suspended or permanently excluded, there should be a transition and participation plan with a named lead responsible for coordinating what happens next. This should be someone within a school in the first instance, and then if a suspension is repeated, escalated to the local authority, so that accountability survives movement between schools, alternative provision and other services. Stronger local school partnerships should support this approach, enabling schools to share expertise, intervene earlier and develop flexible alternatives to exclusion. Teachers participating in DfE’s School Exclusion Trial highlighted the benefits of stronger partnership working, with participating schools reporting earlier intervention, better tracking of vulnerable pupils and fewer permanent exclusions. Over time, this should help reduce both the overall use of exclusion and the significant variation between local areas, while ensuring that those who do leave mainstream education receive high-quality alternative provision with clear routes back into education, training or employment.
Chapter 4 · Identifying and acting on riskChapter 1 · A new participation system
Mayors take on participation from 16 to 24
Paragraph 126Recommendation“Mayors should work through one shared Area Youth Participation Plan, agreed with their constituent councils, the NHS, education and skills providers, employment services, employers, the voluntary sector and young people.”
In short: Strategic authorities become responsible for participation up to age 24. Local authorities keep their duties for 16 and 17 year olds.
Read paragraph 126 in full
Thirdly, I propose that strategic authorities in England should be responsible for the participation system across ages 16 to 24 within their areas, with local authorities remaining the local backbone and retaining their statutory responsibilities for 16 and 17 year-olds. This extension to age 24 is a fundamental change. At present, the state’s responsibility for young people falls away after age 18. Mayors should work through one shared Area Youth Participation Plan, agreed with their constituent councils, the NHS, education and skills providers, employment services, employers, the voluntary sector and young people. That Plan should be the vehicle for those institutions to align around shared objectives and to commit pooled resources. Every area should have mandatory priority-cohort plans, to address the needs of the most at-risk groups (such as disabled people and carers) and identify the immediate actions that can be taken to narrow the gaps in their participation rates. A place cannot claim success if its average improves while the young people with the greatest barriers are left behind.
Chapter 1 · A new participation systemChapter 7 · One Area Youth Participation Plan for each place
Plans linked to prevention from key stage 3
Paragraph 866Recommendation“Every strategic authority, or equivalent lead arrangement in England, will publish an Area Youth Participation Plan covering ages 16 to 24 and linked to prevention and destination planning from key stage 3.”
In short: Every area publishes a plan for ages 16 to 24, built with schools, colleges, employers, the NHS and young people.
Read paragraph 866 in full
Every strategic authority, or equivalent lead arrangement in England, will publish an Area Youth Participation Plan covering ages 16 to 24 and linked to prevention and destination planning from key stage 3. The Plan will be co-created with local employers, local authorities, the local NHS, schools, colleges and training providers, the voluntary and community sector and young people. Young people and employers will be partners in shaping the plan, not consultees brought in after the important decisions have been made.
Chapter 7 · One Area Youth Participation Plan for each placeChapter 7 · Priority cohorts: closing the participation gaps
Three priority groups in every plan
Paragraph 869Recommendation“Every Area Youth Participation Plan will contain 3 mandatory priority-cohort sections focused on the young people facing the greatest barriers to participation.”
In short: Each area sizes the gap for its priority groups, names an accountable lead and publishes how it will close the gap.
Read paragraph 869 in full
Every Area Youth Participation Plan will contain 3 mandatory priority-cohort sections focused on the young people facing the greatest barriers to participation. These are not separate plans, programmes or services. They are the means by which a universal guarantee is made equal in practice. Each section will identify the size of the cohort, the participation gap, the points at which young people are being lost, how they will be identified and reached, the specialist support and employer opportunities required, the accountable lead and a published trajectory for narrowing the gap.
Chapter 7 · Priority cohorts: closing the participation gapsChapter 7 · Priority cohorts: closing the participation gaps
Who the priority groups are
Paragraph 870Recommendation“Each cohort plan should demonstrate how employment and participation gaps will be closed.”
In short: SEND and health conditions; care experience, young carers and young parents; and young people who are hidden, excluded or facing several disadvantages at once.
Read paragraph 870 in full
The first will cover disabled young people, young people with SEND and those with serious or long-term health conditions. The second will cover care-experienced young people and those carrying significant caring or parenting responsibilities, including care leavers, young carers and young parents. The third will cover young people who are hidden, excluded or facing multiple disadvantage, such as those facing homelessness or family crisis, young people in or leaving the justice system, and those with repeated or long NEET spells. Each cohort plan should demonstrate how employment and participation gaps will be closed.
Chapter 7 · Priority cohorts: closing the participation gapsChapter 7 · A clear division of responsibility
An Area Youth Participation Plan that does work
Paragraph 864Recommendation“It should show where young people are being lost, what opportunity and support are required, what resources are available, what each partner will do and who is accountable for the result.”
In short: An operating document showing where young people are lost, what each partner will do and who is accountable.
Read paragraph 864 in full
To support this, they will assess the needs of the NEET and at-risk cohort, prepare a local Area Youth Participation Plan, map demand and opportunity for education, employment and training (building up from local authority-level assessments of sufficiency), align employment, skills, health, transport and wider support, coordinate local employers and public-sector anchor institutions, commission provision and hold the delivery system to account. The Plan should remain an operating document, not become another local strategy. It should show where young people are being lost, what opportunity and support are required, what resources are available, what each partner will do and who is accountable for the result.
Chapter 7 · A clear division of responsibilityChapter 7 · A clear division of responsibility
Mayors answer for the whole system
Paragraph 863Recommendation“But they must be responsible for making sure the system works as a whole: that young people are identified, the Guarantees are delivered, gaps between services are closed and local provision adds up.”
In short: Strategic authorities make sure young people are found, the guarantees are delivered and the gaps between services close.
Read paragraph 863 in full
Mayors and strategic authorities, or an agreed equivalent arrangement where the devolution architecture is still developing, will become accountable for the coherence of the overall 16 to 24 year-old system. They will be the strategic commissioner of local YOS services, responsible for ensuring that the Opportunity and Support Guarantees are delivered and will ensure that all young people can make successful transitions into education, employment and training. They will not employ every member of staff or deliver every service themselves. But they must be responsible for making sure the system works as a whole: that young people are identified, the Guarantees are delivered, gaps between services are closed and local provision adds up. Central government, in turn, must be accountable for whether the national framework, funding and non-devolved services make that local responsibility possible.
Chapter 7 · A clear division of responsibilityChapter 7 · Data that turns visibility into action
Data must lead to a named action
Paragraph 890Recommendation“Better data must trigger a named action by a named service, not simply produce a better dashboard.”
In short: Data only counts when it leads to a person making contact, by a named service.
Read paragraph 890 in full
Data only matters if it leads to human contact. The Dutch experience makes that principle concrete: tracking information is used to identify young people who have disappeared from education or work, but outreach workers then go into neighbourhoods to make contact. The same rule will govern the architecture here. Better data must trigger a named action by a named service, not simply produce a better dashboard.
Chapter 7 · Data that turns visibility into actionChapter 7 · Data that turns visibility into action
The signs are visible, but in pieces
Paragraph 888Evidence“Much of the information already exists, but in fragments.”
In short: Absence sits in a school register, a health problem with the GP, a placement in a local authority file. Nobody joins them up.
Read paragraph 888 in full
The warning signs that a young person is at risk of becoming detached are often visible, but in different parts of the system. Persistent absence may sit in a school register, a health problem in a GP record, a care placement in a council file, a benefit claim in a DWP system and employment or earnings information in HMRC data. Much of the information already exists, but in fragments. What is missing is the legal route, ethical framework, common standards and shared infrastructure needed to turn those fragments into timely action.
Chapter 7 · Data that turns visibility into actionChapter 7 · Data that turns visibility into action
One plan, one named lead, no retelling
Paragraph 892Recommendation“Third, coordinated case management: allowing authorised practitioners to maintain one plan, share case notes, record a named lead and manage handovers without repeatedly asking the young person to retell their story.”
In short: Practitioners keep one plan, share notes, record a named lead and hand over without the young person telling their story again.
Read paragraph 892 in full
The architecture will support 4 connected uses. First, strategic intelligence: giving local and strategic authorities a comprehensive picture of needs, provision gaps and participation patterns. Second, identification and engagement: enabling accountable services to find young people who are NEET, at risk, precariously attached or not known and make timely contact. Third, coordinated case management: allowing authorised practitioners to maintain one plan, share case notes, record a named lead and manage handovers without repeatedly asking the young person to retell their story. Fourth, outcomes and learning: recording what support was offered and received, tracking sustained destinations and improving future commissioning.
Chapter 7 · Data that turns visibility into actionChapter 1 · Reasons to believe
Around 100 local authorities have NEET taskforces
Paragraph 154Evidence“Around 100 local authorities have established taskforces to reduce local NEET rates.”
In short: The country has started to move since the interim report, with local authorities, employers and charities setting up local action.
Read paragraph 154 in full
Third, since the interim report was published, something important has happened. The country has begun to mobilise. Around 100 local authorities have established taskforces to reduce local NEET rates. Employers, charities and community organisations have begun creating more opportunities for young people.
Chapter 1 · Reasons to believeChapter 7 · A Youth Opportunity Service: one route through the system
Local authorities remain the backbone at 16 and 17
Paragraph 838Recommendation“Between the ages of 16 and 17, local authorities’ existing tracking and participation responsibilities will form the local backbone, with the YOS actively contacting young people whose intended destination does not begin or where it starts to break down.”
In short: Local authority tracking stays in place, and the YOS contacts any young person whose next step does not start or falls apart.
Read paragraph 838 in full
Between the ages of 16 and 17, local authorities’ existing tracking and participation responsibilities will form the local backbone, with the YOS actively contacting young people whose intended destination does not begin or where it starts to break down.
Chapter 7 · A Youth Opportunity Service: one route through the systemChapter 7 · The fault line at age 18
Responsibility stops at 18
Paragraph 806Evidence“A birthday should not bring the state’s responsibility for a young person’s future to an end.”
In short: Local authorities track young people until 18. After that, nobody has to know whether a young person is participating.
Read paragraph 806 in full
The sharpest fault line is at age 18. Before then, local authorities have duties to identify and track a young person’s participation. Beyond 18 there is no equivalent responsibility to know whether every young person is participating, find them when they are not or remain responsible for re-engagement. The system can therefore lose continuity at precisely the point when a young person is moving from education into adult working life. A birthday should not bring the state’s responsibility for a young person’s future to an end.
Chapter 7 · The fault line at age 18
Everything quoted is from the review itself, with paragraph numbers as in the published PDF.
Keep going
- Where would a pupil slip through?Ten questions, with a short report on where to start.Take the check
- Ask the Milburn reviewA question in your own words, answered from the paragraphs.Ask a question
- How far is your area from zero?16 and 17 year olds who are NEET or not known, by local authority.Find your local authority